Case Study: Genetics Society of America—How Overleaf Streamlines Editorial Processes
Mary Anne · June 30, 201770% of all accepted
In this Case Study we are delighted to share some of the Genetics Society of America’s experiences of using Overleaf and how it has made a very tangible and positive contribution to their publishing operations—and been welcomed by their author community. Today, 70% of all accepted
The Overleaf team are grateful to the GSA for their assistance during preparation of this Case Study.
Executive summary
The Genetics Society of America (GSA) editorial team was looking for a way to simplify and ease the
- To simplify the
submission and publication process: - to improve the consistency of formatting for newly-submitted articles prepared with
—minimizing the time required to review articles; - to improve completeness of file submissions by helping authors to consistently submit all necessary files—decreasing the time required to chase authors for missing files and information;
- to receive
files which were technically up-to-date and able to compile without errors—reducing time required to debug files and/or pass files back to authors for updates. - To outsource
author support. - To be seen as a technology innovator—by authors and within the GSA.
Key results and conclusions
Here is a short summary of the main outcomes from the partnership between the GSA and Overleaf:
- 70% of all accepted
submissions coming into the The Genetics Society of America’s GENETICS journal are now written and submitted using the Overleaf template and platform. - The GSA gained a deeper understanding of their author-base through data and analytical information provided by Overleaf services.
- There was greater use of, and compliance with, GSA’s published guidelines and templates.
- The GSA’s editorial team observed considerable time savings when processing
-based article submissions produced via Overleaf. - Articles prepared and submitted via Overleaf contain significantly fewer
-related errors than those prepared outside of Overleaf.
Overleaf can also make a significant contribution to the peer review process by enabling authors to easily produce well-prepared papers—Professor Mark Johnston, Editor-in-Chief of GENETICS, noted that:
“I’m always glad when I open up a new submission and see that the authors have used Overleaf to prepare their manuscript. It makes it easier for me to evaluate the manuscript, and I know reviewers appreciate the easy-to-navigate format. I wish all authors would use Overleaf to format their submissions.”
Challenges
Prior to partnering with Overleaf, the Genetics Society of America’s editorial team dreaded seeing
Furthermore, authors were contacting the GSA with
Overleaf proposed as a solution
Professor James Bull of The University of Texas, and former Editor of the GENETICS journal, discovered Overleaf and saw the potential benefits—both for the GSA and their community of authors. He showed the Overleaf platform to GSA’s editorial team and explained how it could save time and streamline their current
Professor Bull said:
“…there is a newinterface that uses journal-specific templates and allows direct submission to journals…
I’m using it for the first time… it looks pretty amazing, both for allowing collaborators to edit the manuscript and for avoiding the hassles of finding all the journal-specific forms. I suspect that something of this ilk will be increasingly common, and indeed the journals could implement templates themselves.”
How Overleaf helped
Overleaf is a cloud-based
Overleaf is also incredibly intuitive and simple to use: just go to the website, open a document template and start to write—there are over 3000 pre-prepared templates to choose from, covering books and journals from many leading publishers. Authors who are new to, or aren’t familiar with,
In addition, Overleaf has Publishing Services which allow publishers to streamline their workflows, provide authors with an innovative author writing experience, greatly simplify the authoring and publishing submission process, and offer
GSA and Overleaf
Partnering with Overleaf provided a comprehensive solution for the Genetics Society of America—it allowed their authors to continue using
Overleaf and the GSA also collaborated on the development of new
To provide a further consistency of working environment for the authors, the Overleaf platform is co-branded, with a journal’s logo and information clearly visible to the author while writing in the journal’s customized template. This visual element acts as confirmation to the author that the Genetics Society of America is working with Overleaf to provide a state-of-the-art authoring experience. Each template includes a simplified submission link that provides a streamlined submission process for the authors. When the author is finished writing (and collaborating!) they simply click a button at the top of the template to submit their article and supporting files to the journal. This simplified submission button provides journal-specific instructions related to the submission process, a link to download all necessary files (including all necessary supplementary files) and a link to the journal’s submission web portal.
Overleaf: support for the GSA
Overleaf’s in-house “
Results
The GENETICS and G3 journal templates were developed and announced to authors within 1–2 months of the initial collaborative discussions between the GSA and Overleaf. Since that time, over the course of 2 years, the templates have been viewed over 15,000 times, with over 1,800 articles worked on and an estimated 214 articles completed or close to completion via the Overleaf platform. 70% of all accepted
“Things are coming in in the proper order and format. We would previously always have to chase authors for additional files (e.g. .sty files). But now we’re getting all we need, we don’t have to chase authors as much. It’s much faster and easier for us to process submissions now.”
Professor Mark Johnston, Editor-in-Chief, GENETICS also comments:
“It’s much easier for me to go through the manuscript and get all the key points out that I need. It’s much easier for me to get to these quickly with an Overleaf manuscript.”
As an author writes and edits in Overleaf, the typeset version of their article is compiled in real-time in a separate window pane on the right-hand side of the screen. This allows the author to see what their finished file will look like, as they’re writing—note that Overleaf’s automatic typesetting/updating can be switched off, for example during periods of heavy editing, and switched on again once it is desirable to do so.
Automatic typesetting/updating helps in two ways:
- Real-time typesetting
compilation) helps to ensure that files are correct and error-free. If an error is introduced by the author, and the file won’t compile, the error is immediately directed into Overleaf's editing environment to alert the author. This early notification allows authors to very quickly detect and correct any errors as they write or edit their paper—thus significantly reducing errors within the final version submitted to the GSA. - It allows the author to continually monitor and visually check the appearance of the typeset document, ensuring that, as far as possible, it adheres to the publisher’s template requirements and generally looks the way it is intended to—for example, tables and figures display correctly. Consistency of article preparation, and adherence to template specifications, allows the GSA to reference author files when composing the finished pages and can also result in authors receiving fewer questions when reviewers and editors review and inspect their paper.
The increasing usage of GSA’s templates, via Overleaf, has reduced the number of questions received from
Ruth Isaacson, Managing Editor, GSA Journals:
“Overleaf decreased the amount of questions we receive and the amount of processing time required fromusers—with Word users we still have to answer a lot of questions, and it takes a lot more of the editorial staff time.”
Unexpected benefits
The Genetics Society of America realized a few unexpected benefits from their partnership with Overleaf, including:
- encouraging more authors (including non-
authors) to use the Overleaf workflow and templates; - gaining a deeper understanding of their author-base;
- improved data and analytics on author writing and template usage.
The GSA is an organization that listens to the needs of their authors and adopts new tools to help them with those needs. Recognized as a technology innovator, the GSA were one of the first publishers to implement Overleaf to support their authors—and the response has been excellent. The GSA understood that Overleaf is positioned as a
Tracey DePellegrin, Executive Editor of the GENETICS and G3 journals, commented that:
“It’s exciting to work with Overleaf to provide our authors with this innovative writing, reviewing and submission tool, which offers a faster and simplerwriting and submission process. Overleaf has helped us to add value to our journals, improving our submission process for both authors, and our editorial office/team.”
An author from the GENETICS journal said:
“I’m very happy to see GENETICS providing this option. I’ve been very pleased with Overleaf and am using it to collaborate with a number of people on different projects. I've recently become so tired of dealing with Word, that I now choose journals for submission based in large part on whether they allowand ease of the submission process... ”
The GSA is now looking to encourage more authors (especially non-users of
Since one of Overleaf’s distinctive and developed features is the option to write in either Rich Text mode or
The GSA intends to further support authors through useful data and analytics associated with the Overleaf
About the GSA
The Genetics Society of America (GSA), founded in 1931, is the professional membership organization for scientific researchers and educators in the field of genetics. Their members work to advance knowledge in the basic mechanisms of inheritance, from the molecular to the population level.
The GENETICS journal
GENETICS is published by the Genetics Society of America, a scholarly society that seeks to deepen our understanding of the living world by advancing our understanding of genetics. Since 1916, GENETICS has published high-quality, original research presenting novel findings bearing on genetics and genomics. The journal publishes empirical studies of organisms ranging from microbes to humans, as well as theoretical work.